if i gave something to a grad student to read, or to anyone for that matter, it would mean that i valued their opinion, and thus, would want any sort of information possible. from their thoughts on the whole paper, to organization, to whats confusing, to whats not needed, to typos.
but this guy sounds like maybe he acts differently (based on your he revises everything). but you gave him a good response though!
--
Posted by strawberries to academicsecret at 11/04/2006 08:12:02 PM
